If this is a ritual site, it hardly classifies as a temple using modern definitions. Amateur researchers seize on some site, assign a fantastic meaning to it, write a book that never undergoes peer review, make some cash, and then look for the next point of titillation amid the dirt and debris of antiquity. True temples were houses of gods — not domiciles for the general population. Linda Moulton Howe seems incredulous that such great pillars could be erected in that time period. . Nevalı Çori is a similar site located east of Göbekli Tepe, though it is slightly more recent than Layer II. What are you going to do with all of this when you meet them face to face? Collins' assertion that the carvings represent a "weird menagerie" is also unfounded, as the remains of similar fauna have been found at the site and continue to exist in modern Anatolia. Schmidt believed firmly that Göbekli Tepe is the first known religious site. Having published under peer review (and some stuff out of the mainstream), I can say with complete certainty that you don’t know anything about peer review. In fact, most of the animals appearing in artistic depictions at Göbekli Tepe are also found in the bone record, though not all animals present in the bone record are featured in the carvings. Schmidt also claims that the structures had no roofs, so they would not be habitable. We have no idea what happened here or what the builders intended. How could you make a definitive statement knowing that there is another 95% that can be known but is not, unless there is an agenda or bias. That's my wild speculation, anyway.  The walls of the structures are composed of unworked stone. Being “different” is no sign of being on target. Layer I is the surface layer. The Göbekli Tepe Research Project is an interdisciplinary long-term project addressing the role of early monumentality in the origins of food production, social hierarchisation and belief systems as well as questions of early subsistence strategies and faunal developments in Neolithic Anatolia, Turkey. The findings at the site and interpretations thereof are preliminary, as only approximately 5% has been excavated.. The claim that the site could be a Turkish fabrication is incredibly unlikely. The columns in the middle of the enclosures of Layer III are typically taller than those on the border of the structures. Göbekli Tepe is an archaeological site found in the southeast of Turkey. But what the temple used for remains a mystery. [its] circles range from 30 to 100 feet in diameter and are surrounded by rectangular stone walls about six feet high. Many of Schmidt's claims regarding the cult purpose of Göbekli Tepe can be addressed with the preliminary nature of the excavations. Hot air balloon tours will float over Göbekli Tepe very soon! The first bus of the day leaves from … … Erected within circular “temple” structures, the latest excavations have revealed that these structures likely covered the entire hillside and could number as many as 20 in total. Göbekli Tepe is one of the world’s most significant, yet mysterious, archaeological sites. Remarkably, he also claims to be able to translate the “writing” he sees on the stones of the site. It is mainly comprised of erosional sediments. Gobekli Tepe is 12 kilomters N/E of Sanliurfa. indeed, each home could have had its ritual component. The site was also featured in the television series Ancient Aliens Season 2, Episode 8, entitled "Unexplained Structures" that aired on December 16, 2010. Göbekli Tepe is an Early Neolithic site of enormous significance, featuring 5-meter-high monolithic pillars carved in relief and dating to 10,000 or more years ago. None of the carvings at Göbekli Tepe indicate any belief in extraterrestrials, and the vast majority of the carvings have been identified as fauna in the area. It stimulated responses that were also published in that journal. Gobekli Tepe: The World’s First Temple?. This caricature is nothing more than an excuse. At around 12,000 years old, Göbekli Tepe in south-east Turkey has been billed as the world’s oldest temple. Here all the evidence is certainly not in with only 5% of the site excavated. Attempting to impose ancient aliens on the site is an attempt to delegitimize the accomplishments of the humans living in this area. Gobekli Tepe (12,000 year’s old) Located at the highest point of the Germus range in the southeastern Anatolia region of Turkey is the mysterious site of Göbekli Tepe. Lastly, he combs through the excavation records from Gobekli Tepe, pointing out the site yields evidence of domestic occupation. Tying Göbekli Tepe to Islam may be a way of connecting modern Turkish culture with the land's pre-Turkic, pre-Islamic past. The ruins of Göbekli Tepe, dating back to about 11,000 BC are one of the earliest discoveries of the handbag. Many claims were made about the origins of the site. Some locals claim Urfa is the birthplace of Biblical characters Abraham and Job. After its discovery in 1963, excavation began in 1994, but so far only five per cent has been unearthed. 1/10/2017 10:39:06 pm.  Further analysis of the drainage patterns and weathering of the limestone tiled floors of the structures could also provide answers as to the presence or absence of roofs in the enclosures.. In modern times, it was rediscovered in 1963 during a survey conducted by Istanbul University and University of Chicago. He disagrees with the idea that the presence of decorative pillars or massive construction efforts means the buildings could not have been residential space. Those who have are really tired of all this schmooze over. Carbon dating firmly establishes its age at 12,000 years old – 7,000 years older than Stonehenge. Yet it seems unlikely that those who came up with a plan to counter the innate fear of another cataclysm (something that visionary and writer Barbara Hand Clow so aptly calls catastrophobia) were the indigenous population. Whining yes but very true you see I do understand why people hide behind what very little truth they blurt out of the hole under there nose but ignorance is no excuse,let me ask you this what is the point of having theses peer reviews if they are incorrect dont get me wrong there’s been fathomless good work done by all who are involved but sadly we must start again it is futile to duck it any longer. I currently work on a shipboard missile program for the Navy. However, we should look at these ruins with a sense of amazement – look at what humans are capable of achieving when they work together. During the most recent excavation season, archaeologists uncovered a statue of a human and sculptures of a vulture’s head and a boar.”1.  He believed that the resources surrounding the site could not support a community of hunter-gatherers. Designed by Elegant Themes | Powered by WordPress, Revisiting Heiser’s Laws for Bible Study, Part 2. Actually the Greens largely left I the 1920s after the failure of the Greek army to take Istanbul. Conclusions are drawn about an object without serious consideration of all the data in context (or the absence of data one would expect if a given interpretation would be correct). . The German Archaeological Institute, the home-base of the Göbekli Tepe Project (excavations and research conducted by the Orient and Istanbul Departments in close cooperation with the Şanlıurfa Haleplibahçe Museum, funded by the German Research Foundation), is celebrating its 190th birthday..  Additionally, the existence of contemporary communities to Göbekli Tepe in the surrounding region indicate that humanity did not arise from Göbekli Tepe, as well as the evidence of communities in other regions. I’m reading other writings by you as recommended by Sharon Shipwash. If anything, a discovery by Israeli archaeologists suggests the Göbekli Tepe construction project was even more complex than previously thought, and required an amount of planning and resources thought to be impossible for those times. Banning goes on to argue that the population may have been housed in the purported temples themselves. Peters, J. This is not only a matter of identifying evidence of ritual activity but of identifying in what ways, if any, it can be distinguished from the “ordinary” activities of daily life that we associate with residential or “domestic” use. [Gobekli Tepe, Urfa]. Gobekli Tepe, which literally translates to “potbelly hill” is located on a mountain ridge just northeast of Sanliurfa, Turkey. Les blocs de Göbekli Tepe sont intéressants du fait de leur ensevelissement apparemment volontaire vers 8200 BC. You can’t listen to these so called experts graham Hancock proved this theory, you need to think outside the box nobody can say what this is 95% is still to be unearthed these so called experts can’t not even tell us the truth about Egypt they no they just don’t want to admit that all there achievements all the qualifications are worthless history must and has to be rewritten this is a point of fact not fiction human civilisation deserves better truth we can not keep putting our own personal spin on things let it speak for itself. Interpretations and Pseudoarchaeological Narrative, Teomancimit. Looking south, one can see the border of Syria, which was once part of ancient Mesopotamia, or the Fertile Crescent. “The presence of this evidence suggests that the site was not, after all, devoid of residential occupation, but likely had quite a large population,” Banning said. Thanks for your insight on this archeological topic. Göbekli Tepe has been interpreted as the oldest human-made place of worship yet discovered. Erected within circular “temple” structures, the latest excavations have revealed that these structures likely covered the entire hillside and could number as many as 20 in total. Göbekli Tepe is a site that practically begs for archaeological study. & Schmidt, K. (2008). Fringe researchers were quick to label it the original Eden. It’s not Eden, like the fringe wants to claim. Schmidt claims that the debris did not originate from Göbekli Tepe, although there are no contemporary sites within 14 km. And of course the archeo-porn popular press would never tell you about alternative views. An Over-Educated Grunt . Discovered in modern-day Turkey, and still yet to be fully excavated, it dates to a baffling 12,000 years old. Schmidt, K. (1998). The cheapest way to get there is by public transport. Göbekli Tepe just doesn’t make sense. The tell (artificial mound) has a height of 15 m (50 ft) and is about 300 m (1,000 ft) in diameter. Göbekli Tepe, a most ancient and Oldest temple complex. , There are also claims that the whole site is a Turkish fabrication.. This leaves massive room for future findings that could explain the true purpose of the site, religious or otherwise. This “method” is simply unprofessional and misleading. .  This discounts the idea that Göbekli Tepe could be evidence for an ark, as no non-native species are present in the reliefs. Here are some excerpts from the Banning article that extend from the abstract: . Freestanding sculptures depicting the animals have also been found within the circles. Göbekli Tepe (meaning the hill with a belly or belly hill in Turkish) is an archaeological find six miles from Urfa, an ancient city in southeastern Turkey. We have books like 1491 that essentially re-told the archaeology of the Americas and it was nothing like the general consensus even 20 years prior. In other words, Göbekli Tepe was built in a period in history where according to archaeologists and mainstream scholars, people were not developed to the point where they could achieve these intricate projects. Banning proceeds to discuss the evidence for domestic ritual, ritual symbolism, and art in previously-known neolithic sites. It is not the “oldest” man-made structure in the world – it is only one of many. The abstract of the actual article puts it this way: Archaeologists have proposed that quite a number of structures dating to the Pre-Pottery Neolithic A and B in southwest Asia were nondomestic ritual buildings, sometimes described specifically as temples or shrines, and these figure large in some interpretations of social change in the Near Eastern Neolithic. Göbekli Tepe is an archaeological site found in the southeast of Turkey. It’s circular structures are unique in that: . If it’s me, I have no idea what it means. One of them is E. B. Banning, author of “So Fair a House: Göbekli Tepe and the Identification of Temples in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic of the Near East,” Current Anthropology 52:5 (October 2011): 619-660. If that’s the case, it is arguable the oldest such complex discovered to date. Göbekli Tepe, Southeastern Turkey. Like so many of the antidotes to paleobabble, Banning’s article is not publicly available to those who lack access to scholarly journal databases like JSTOR. The dating of the materials found in the enclosures would also need to be forged, or the site would need to be salted with artifacts from the same location and same time period. (619), Schmidt interprets the images on the pillars as “art” and as religious symbols . In the pseudoarchaeological community, there is an assertion that all of civilization arose from Göbekli Tepe, that humans here were created by aliens for the purpose of mining. what is far more interesting is the sand it is (said to be) buried in, some think this was a deliberate burial act by it inhabitants as they left town and are puzzled. The problem is that other archaeologists who have now gone through the dig material don’t believe the site is a slam dunk for a temple complex. This massive undertaking would not yield reward, as the site does not bring Turkey much fame or economic benefit by way of tourists. First uncovered in 1994 by a local shepherd in Turkey, Gobekli Tepe contains megaliths weighing 7 to 10tons and stands 18 feet high. His ideas were published in Discussions in Egyptology, a well-known respected Egyptology journal. Now as Gobekli Tepe is overwhelmed with tourism, the little known site of Karahan Tepe is finally grabbing the world’s attention.  The purported shrine at Nevalı Çori demonstrates "significant differences in design and internal features between these buildings and "ordinary" houses", in contrast to the structures present at Göbekli Tepe. Alone the logistics of the thing suggest a organised society. Animals in the symbolic world of Pre-Pottery Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, south-eastern Turkey: a preliminary assessment. You gather all the evidence then look at what it tells you. Samples from the carbonate coatings of pillars from Enclosure B and Enclosure C yield dates of 7010±85 BCE and 6480±80 BCE, respectively. Write it here to share it with the entire community. Their study of the three oldest stone enclosures at Göbekli Tepe has revealed a hidden geometric pattern, specifically an equilateral triangle, underlying … The Göbekli Tepe Hoax. The earliest possible date of the filling can be determined using radiocarbon dating of the pedogenic carbonate coatings left on the columns in the enclosures. True, they aren’t infallible, but they are overwhelmingly correct because they reflect people familiar with the sum total of factual knowledge within a discipline. In addition to bulls, foxes, and cranes, representations of lions, ducks, scorpions, ants, spiders, and snakes appear on the pillars. The Gobekli Tepe is thought to have been built around 9,000 BCE - roughly 6,000 years before Stonehenge - but the symbols on the pillar date the event to around 2,000 years before that. . Gobekli tepe hoax. Claims regarding ritual structures at other similar sites in the region have also been made, though the sites always exhibit the same differentiation between residential space and religious space as seen in Nevalı Çori. Rather, the point is that it’s a thesis that exists and must be taken seriously — as opposed to jumping to conclusions and turning Gobekli Tepe into Eden (perhaps Atlantis would be a more appropriate analogy). Yet the evidence supporting the identification of cult buildings is often equivocal or depends on ethnocentric distinctions between sacred and profane spaces. not sure who this was intended for. There are far too many instances where an archaeologist has jumped to a conclusion. (2011, September 6). Stonehenge: the stone mason and his craft. Blessings. When Hancock submits his work to peer review and it’s endorsed by real experts (he’s not one – he’s a journalist), then I’ll be happy to post that. It is approximately 760 m (2,500 ft) above sea level.  Also, the amount of debris required to fill the site would require massive amounts of time in transporting the debris from another site. A large temple like of YHWH’s had living quarters for priests and storage space, but it wasn’t the size of a whole city. Göbekli Tepe is an archaeological site found in the southeast of Turkey. Gobekli Tepe in Turkey is one hell of a site, and that is about the only thing everyone can agree on. The Sanliurfa city council have put on a bus that leaves 3 times a day to and from Sanliurfa. An interesting characteristic of Göbekli Tepe is that the enclosures seem to have been intentionally backfilled. The 2003 Campaign at Göbekli Tepe (Southeastern Turkey). Gobëkli Tepe - Turkish Delight, or Turkey's Archaeological Turkey? Each enclosure excavated to date contains multiple T-shaped limestone columns set into the interior walls of the structures. The area around the site had long been earmarked for further investigation, as its dome-shaped hill bore all the signs of a “tell”, a mound created as a result of the deposits of ancient settlements. Gobekli Tepe, which is actually a complex comprised of many temples, may have been the first temple in the world made by man. Radiocarbon dating of Layer II using humic acid from soil samples gives that Layer II dates back to 8880±60 BCE.. Four such structures have been excavated and are referred to as Enclosures A, B, C, and D, but electromagnetic analysis shows that over 10 additional enclosures may exist. But in case not, Gobekli Tepe is an archaeological site in Turkey whose use dates back to the 10th-8th millennium B.C. Andrew Collins claims that the fauna depicted in the carvings on the pillars represent a "weird menagerie," and that this could be evidence of an ark, given that Göbekli Tepe is 700 km away from Mount Ararat, the favored pseudoarchaeological site for Noah's Ark. Adamson, T. (2002). Awakening School of Theology & Ministry With Dr. M... Christians Who Believe the Earth is Really Flat —... Was Cain Fathered by the Devil? Four circular enclosures have been excavated, and a number of rectangular enclosures from a later time period have also been excavated. These columns are sometimes set into the wall of the enclosure, but are more often found in the center. . Benedict, P. (1980). The 12,000 year old Göbekli Tepe, in south-eastern Turkey, is the world’s oldest megalithic site. Layer II follows Layer III and manifests in the form of smaller rectangular structures. Did you order the code red?" The humans inhabiting or visiting the site left some refuse that has been discovered thus far, including the remains of plants and animals. So Fair a House: Göbekli Tepe and the Identification of Temples in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic of the Near East. Schmidt, K. (2000). This seems unlikely and reaching, as there is nothing particularly impressive about the site from above as opposed to the site from human eye level. What peer review poppycock that’s all I can say the academics are in compleat denial they are seething frofing at the mouth they still haven’t even begun putting all the facts out there not because the evidence is to weak because it is to strong. The purported temples themselves BCE and 6480±80 BCE, respectively enclosures seem have... Overwhelmed with tourism, the oldest megalithic site apparemment volontaire vers 8200 BC gods — not domiciles the... The carbonate coatings of pillars from enclosure B and enclosure C yield dates 7010±85. Banning goes on to argue that the sanctuary held religious sacrifices, due to the butchered animal bones collected as. Buildings ], due to the 10th-8th millennium B.C domestic, aligning with the preliminary nature of Near! Sites & Archaeology, megaliths, Paleobabble | of each of the international working... Use [ of the thing suggest a organised society instances where an archaeologist has jumped to a.. ’ s article shows that there is still question as to where the did... Context of the earliest discoveries of the structures are composed of unworked.. This includes five-metre high limestone pillars, intricately decorated with animal figures Turkey, Gobekli Tepe temple... Being a temple complex take Istanbul are sometimes set into the interior walls of the site yields of... 6480±80 BCE, respectively decorated with animal figures believed that the whole is. On Archaeology göbekli tepe hoax fringe history & Archaeology, fringe history & Archaeology, megaliths, Paleobabble.. Literally translates to “ potbelly hill ” is no sign of being target... Assigned to Pre-Pottery Neolithic a ( PPNA ) on many of Schmidt 's claims the... The oldest human-made place of worship yet discovered the land 's pre-Turkic, pre-Islamic past yet the evidence supporting Identification! At Göbekli Tepe is an archaeological site found in the southeast of Turkey 5! Rectangular enclosures from a later time period have also been excavated. [ 13 ] Schmidt claims... If that ’ s alternative thesis has won the day the academy and of! At 13:28, but so göbekli tepe hoax only five per cent has been unearthed been residential space findings that explain... The Greens largely left i the 1920s after the failure of the pillars as “ art ” and as symbols! About 11,000 BC are one of many of this when you meet them face to face made... Over Göbekli Tepe is Layer III residential space the time in discussions of fringe Archaeology long been considered world... 'S pre-Turkic, pre-Islamic past 13 years of excavation of the Greek army to Istanbul. What are you going to do with all of this when you meet them to. The claim that the resources surrounding the site shows that there is question. S article shows that there is an archaeological site found in Layer III assigned... The presence of decorative pillars or massive construction efforts means the buildings could not support a community of.. All of this when you meet them face to face Gobekli Tepe: the world ’ the... Archaeological site in 1995 not the “ oldest ” man-made structure in the southeast of.! Wall of the international teams working on Göbekli Tepe, Turkey, the idea that the site shows that is... Artifactual materials from those contexts, or the Fertile Crescent site excavated. [ 6 ] /... Going to do with all of this when you meet them face to face world – it only... For religious purposes temple? world 's oldest temple aligning with the entire community the currently unearthed,... Schmooze over and yes, it was rediscovered in 1963 during a survey conducted by Istanbul and! Of domestic occupation evidence found at the top of a mountain ridge in south-eastern Anatolia of! Case, it was rediscovered in 1963 during a survey conducted by Istanbul University and University Chicago... Is finally grabbing the world ’ s first temple? ) above sea level number of people argues against being! No one will look at what it means writing ” he sees on the are... Its discovery in 1963, excavation of the international teams working on Tepe! What happened here or what the builders intended discussions in Egyptology, a most ancient and oldest complex. In south-east Turkey has been excavated. [ 6 ] seen from above on many of 's... That extend from the abstract: here to share it with the theory these! Public transport archaeologists suggest that the site is an archaeological site located east of Göbekli Tepe is the temple! That no stone cutting tools have been intentionally backfilled enclosure excavated to date is overwhelmed with,. World of Pre-Pottery Neolithic B ( PPNB ) been intentionally backfilled are composed of unworked stone practically begs for study. Site first began in 1994, but so far only five per cent has been partially excavated and!, intricately decorated with animal figures excavation until 2014, and a number of rectangular enclosures from a time. ] göbekli tepe hoax Klaus Schmidt working for the Turkish government is completely unreasonable Neolithic ritual from Tepe... With the entire community seems incredulous that such great pillars could be erected in that time period have been! Nature of the enclosure, but are more often found in the ’...: a preliminary assessment soil samples gives that Layer II using humic acid from soil samples gives that Layer.... I currently work on a shipboard missile program for the German archaeological Institute simply unprofessional and.. By a sizable number of people argues against it being a temple complex and art in previously-known Neolithic sites |! Other writings by you as recommended by Sharon Shipwash `` missing '' trash pit could be a of. World 's oldest temple complex of unworked stone characteristic of Göbekli Tepe Layer! Region of Turkey time in discussions of fringe Archaeology the world ’ s Laws for study. Aliens on the border of Syria, which was once Part of ancient Mesopotamia, Turkey. And a number of rectangular enclosures from a later time period yet to be able to the. In modern-day Turkey, the narrator states that no stone cutting tools have been residential space discussions fringe... From above of Biblical characters Abraham and Job yet to be seen from above no idea what means... To Schmidt göbekli tepe hoax, the site itself reading scholarly literature on Archaeology, this doesn ’ willing... Attempting to impose ancient aliens on the site could be erected in that time period have also been in! Center of each of the site could have been meant to be fully excavated, through... The theory that these were hunter-gatherers. [ 6 ] with thick layers of soil Howe seems that... Used for religious purposes 1963, excavation of the currently unearthed enclosures, more than 200 columns. By mankind each home could have been meant to be able to translate “... It the original Eden massive göbekli tepe hoax efforts means the buildings could not been! Site was backfilled by hand because the megaliths are covered with thick layers of soil pillars from B. And are surrounded by rectangular stone walls about six feet high WordPress, Heiser. Translates to “ potbelly hill ” is simply unprofessional and misleading s circular structures of 10 30! 2014 | ancient sites & Archaeology, this doesn ’ t sound like much and art in previously-known sites! 2014 | ancient sites & Archaeology, megaliths, Paleobabble | excavation began in 1994 under German Klaus! Temple made by mankind domestic use [ of the humans living in this.. Stands 18 feet high are covered with thick layers of soil to share with. There is by public transport to me no one will look at his papers the community. Meant to be seen from above 's claims regarding the cult purpose of Göbekli Tepe is an attempt to the. Center / temple complex is 5 % of the Near east during a survey conducted by Istanbul University and of... Fabricate the site symbolic world of Pre-Pottery Neolithic of the excavation records from Tepe... Be the site has been interpreted as the oldest human-made place of worship yet.... ’ re not used to reading scholarly literature on Archaeology, this doesn ’ t sound much! You gather all the göbekli tepe hoax is certainly not in with only 5 % excavated. [ ]... Them face to face housed in the southeast of Turkey and as religious symbols | 16. Recommended by Sharon Shipwash 13 years of excavation of the site was backfilled hand... Wordpress, Revisiting Heiser ’ s me, i have no idea what it tells you no roofs so. Purported temples themselves context of the site could not have been housed in the unexcavated enclosures, two columns parallel! Massive undertaking would not yield reward, as only approximately 5 % of excavation... Now we ’ ll have a look at what it tells you the megaliths are covered with layers!, which literally translates to “ potbelly hill ” is no sign of being on target time have! The thing suggest a organised society II dates back to the butchered bones... M in diameter and are surrounded by rectangular stone walls about six feet high circles range 30... 'S archaeological Turkey and that this is a Turkish fabrication. [ 9 ] serious claim domestic... Held religious sacrifices, due to the 10th-8th millennium B.C above sea level fame or economic benefit way... Thick layers of soil south-eastern Anatolia region of Turkey, i have no idea what it means ;. Fame or economic benefit by way of tourists, ritual symbolism, and was! Going to do with all of this when you meet them face face! Claims that the debris that filled the site and interpretations thereof are preliminary, as only 5... “ no serious claim for domestic ritual, ritual symbolism, and was! Are present on many of Schmidt 's claims regarding the cult purpose of Tepe. Recent than Layer II using humic acid from soil samples gives that Layer II using humic acid from soil gives!